Re-Imagining Pakistan: Security State or Welfare State?

Barrister Hamid (Late) was an intellectual and author.  In a talk, he highlighted that for 75 years, the country has been run under a security state narrative led by the military establishment, leaving little room for welfare-based policies.

He pointed out that Pakistan’s political parties, often run like family businesses, have failed to provide solutions. Meanwhile, the establishment continues to justify its dominance through threats of external interference, especially in regions like Balochistan.

Hamid rejected the idea of India’s direct control in Balochistan, calling it a myth used to suppress voices. He argued that Pakistan must move towards a welfare-oriented social contract, warning that otherwise “things will not be good for the people.”

He emphasized historical grievances, particularly in Balochistan, where resources like Sui gas (natural gas) were extracted but never benefited locals for decades. Despite contributing 43% of Pakistan’s land area, Balochistan remains the most underdeveloped province, with poverty and lack of basic facilities fueling resentment.

By revisiting history, from Jinnah’s promises to princely states to later forced integrations, which sowed seeds of mistrust. He underlined that constitutional arrangements were bypassed, creating long-term instability.

The debate concluded that Pakistan’s reliance on a security-first approach has led to internal unrest and aggressive foreign policy. A shift towards welfare, fairness in resource distribution, and addressing sub-nationalist grievances could provide sustainable peace and unity. 

Popular posts from this blog

The Facade of Power: Unraveling Body Doubles, De-Dollarization, and Global Shifts

The Summit's Shocking Revelation: A Body Double in the Spotlight In a tale that reads like a thriller from the shadows of international intrigue, the Alaska Peace Summit unfolded with an unexpected twist. What was billed as a pivotal meeting between President Trump and Vladimir Putin turned heads not for diplomatic breakthroughs, but for the glaring signs that the Russian leader present was no more than a body double. As the thumbnail suggested and reactions poured in, the fake Putin's awkward expressions and uncharacteristic behaviors stood out starkly. From the moment he stepped off the plane, his reactions to B-2 bombers pointed out by Trump—wide-eyed surprise like a child rather than a seasoned statesman—screamed impostor. Observers noted how real Putin never cranes his neck upward in that manner, a detail honed from years of scrutinizing his body language. Media channels later dissected the anomalies: the right hand's unnatural movements, an overly joyful smile to the ...
Read more

The Dollar, Proxies, and the Changing Global Order

For decades, the narrative in India was built on the belief that China and Pakistan were the eternal enemies . Experts taught this line consistently for 30 years. But as events unfolded, it has become increasingly clear that the real force propping up these two adversaries was never just their own strength. Instead, it was the power of the US dollar that stood behind the Chinese Communist Party and the Pakistan Army. Today, with military setbacks exposing the limits of these proxies, a new reality is unfolding in the global arena. The Exposure of Proxies China’s military tried its hand in Galwan and retreated after heavy losses. Pakistan’s army was tested in surgical strikes, Balakot, and now Operation Sindoor —each time ending up defeated and humiliated. The once-feared proxies, nurtured by dollar-driven systems, have been dismantled militarily. Now, “Uncle Sam” himself has stepped onto the front foot, declaring openly that the real villain is the US system that stood behind these ...
Read more

Revolutionary Reforms: Holding Leaders Accountable and Shaping India's Future

A Historic Shift in Indian Democracy In a landmark move that echoes the spirit of true accountability since India's independence in 1947, Home Minister Amit Shah introduced three bills, with the most pivotal one aimed at fortifying democracy. For the first time in the nation's history, top officials—including the Prime Minister, Chief Ministers, and Ministers—will be held directly accountable to the public. If convicted of a serious offense or crime and sentenced to more than 30 days in jail, they must resign. Failure to do so will result in an automatic resignation. This reform, hailed as the biggest democratic overhaul post-1947, ensures that no one can cling to power amid grave misconduct. The genesis of this bill traces back to controversies like the excise liquor scam involving Arvind Kejriwal, where ministers were caught in scandals, including the construction of a lavish Sheesh Mahal. Despite arrests, attempts to run cabinets from jail persisted, with no signs of resigna...
Read more